Leasing return: What damages do you have to pay for?

Lease return: What damages do you have to pay for? (Photo: © kritchanut/123RF.com)

Read aloud:

Leasing return: What damages do you have to pay for?

It's important for lessees to know: The car doesn't have to be in perfect new condition upon return. The lessee is not responsible for normal wear and tear.

If damage exceeds normal wear and tear, the lessee is only liable for the diminished value , not the repair costs . The lessee is only liable for excessive wear and tear (Section 538 of the German Civil Code). This refers to damage that could have been avoided with proper use. The standard is the condition of the vehicle corresponding to its age and mileage.

Small scratches and dents are normal signs of wear

Normal wear and tear typically includes small stone chips or minor scratches and scrapes near the fuel filler cap, door handles, and trunk handles. Using car washes can also cause scratches on the roof and front and rear hatches. Minor dents on three doors and the right rear quarter panel are typical signs of wear and tear from driving in heavy traffic and tight parking conditions. Such damage is therefore not considered excessive wear and tear (see the judgment of the Munich Regional Court I, judgment of October 9, 1996, case no. 15 S 9301/96). The same should apply to paint chipping on the door edges.

In case of wear and tear, only pay the reduced value

In cases of excessive wear and tear , the costs to be reimbursed are not those necessary to repair the damage, but only the amount by which the value of the vehicle has been reduced (Regional Court of Frankfurt, judgment of September 16, 1997, case no. 2/8 S 79/97, 2-08 S 79/97). The individual damages may not simply be added together, but must be considered in their entirety.

What to consider when leasing a vehicle: How to avoid pitfalls when leasing a vehicle > Read more here!

You might also be interested in:

Lessor must provide evidence 

The lessor bears the burden of proof; that is, they must provide detailed evidence and demonstrate which of the alleged damages are attributable to normal wear and tear and which to excessive wear and tear. An expert opinion that simply lists the damage costs without any justification is insufficient . In court proceedings, they cannot merely name the expert commissioned to prepare the report as a witness, as demonstrating excessive wear and tear is the lessor's responsibility (Korbach Local Court, Judgment of July 27, 1999, Case No. 3 C 32/99).

For example, the lessor does not fulfill their burden of proof if they only commission an expert more than two weeks after the vehicle's return . Furthermore, to secure evidence, they must issue a specific order to determine any excessive wear and tear.

If the lessee wants to play it safe and independent opinion would like to obtain he should contact a specialist for leasing returns, who can, among other things, even take care of returning the car to the leasing company. Tip: Don't approach returns unprepared.
Before returning a leased vehicle, business owners should review the lessor's damage catalog and document the vehicle themselves – ideally with photos of the paintwork, rims, interior, tires, and service records. For any visible damage, a preliminary inspection can help to better estimate the anticipated costs. The return protocol should only be signed if all information is correct. Disputed damage should be recorded in writing. The decisive factor is not the repair invoice, but the actual diminished value of the vehicle; this is not subject to VAT.

Lessee must confirm return protocol

The lessor must compensate for excessive Wear and tear in you Return protocol record, supplement with photographs in case of doubt and be submitted by the lessee to confirm (LG Frankfurt, judgment of 25.07.1988, Az. 2/24 S 354/86). If a residual value settlement is agreed in the contract, the Billing clause be checked, because such contract arrangements can ineffective Furthermore, the lessor is not entitled to VAT on any reduced value.

Leasing Billing: What you have to pay if you return your leased vehicle early > Read more here Diesel Scandal: No compensation for leasing a cheat diesel ! > Read more here! DHB now also digital! Simply click here and register for the digital DHB!

Text: / handwerksblatt.de

You might also be interested in: