Defective electric car: Quarantine in case of fire risk, but not permanently
Those who tow and store electric vehicles can charge for special safety measures. However, they are only allowed to do so for five days, provided there is no immediate fire hazard, ruled the Koblenz Regional Court.
What special considerations apply when towing a damaged electric vehicle ? Is a quarantine parking space required, and if so, for how long? How is the fire risk assessed, and what is a reasonable parking fee ? These were the questions the Koblenz Regional Court had to decide.
The case
Following an accident involving a hybrid car, a company towed the vehicle and stored it on its premises. Because the damaged battery allegedly posed a fire hazard , the company charged storage and maintenance fees for a period of approximately one and a half years.
The other driver's liability insurance paid approximately €5.459 for the storage time. However, the towing company demanded an additional €38.569,81 from the vehicle owner . They argued that the vehicle, due to its damaged lithium-ion battery, required a separate quarantine parking space and regular monitoring. They claimed that €95 per day was the standard and reasonable rate for this.
The judgment
The Koblenz Regional Court ruled that the towing service could not demand the full costs . It was only entitled to storage fees of €7.596,96 based on an implied safekeeping agreement pursuant to Sections 688 and 689 of the German Civil Code (BGB) . The bill for storing the hybrid car was deemed disproportionately high.
The company can only charge for the first five days of a quarantine parking space. This is because a hybrid vehicle, after an accident like the one in question, is more likely to catch fire than conventional vehicles. This necessitates parking the vehicle in a quarantine area. After hearing expert testimony, the court set the costs at €76,16 gross per day.
Only five days of quarantine
According to the expert opinion, the Regional Court was also convinced that the damaged electric vehicle could be stored conventionally after five days because no reaction or incident had occurred with the battery by then. Fire departments recommend monitoring damaged high-voltage vehicles for at least 72 hours or parking them in quarantine areas. The German Association of Recovery and Towing Companies (VBA) estimates up to 120 hours, which corresponds to five days.
For the subsequent 379-day period , the court only charged the cost of a standard parking space . It estimated this at €19,04 gross per day. This resulted in a total parking fee of €7.596,96.
Koblenz Regional Court, Judgment of May 4, 2026, Case No. 14 O 169/24
The advisors at the Chambers of Crafts will be happy to help you with any legal questions!
DHB now also available digitally! Simply click here and register for the digital German Crafts Journal (DHB)!
Text:
Anne Kieserling /
handwerksblatt.de
Write a comment